Sign in to share
Shikha Sharma
My husband and I did not achieve comfortable silence for at least two years.
I want to be clear about what I mean by comfortable silence. I don't mean the silence after a fight, which is its own specific category of terrible. I don't mean the silence of two people who have run out of things to say. I mean the good silence. The silence of two people in the same room, each doing their own thing, completely at ease, not performing togetherness but just existing in it.
That silence took us a while.
In the beginning, every silence felt like something that needed to be filled. We'd be sitting together and one of us would feel the quiet and immediately say something, anything, just to fill the space. It was exhausting. We were basically running a two-person talk show with no breaks, no ad slots, and no clear end time.
I remember one Sunday afternoon in our first year. We were both trying to read. Every few minutes one of us would look up and say something unnecessary. "What are you reading?" I'd already told him. "Do you want tea?" We'd just had tea. "Should we do something today?" We were doing something. We were reading. It was a perfectly good activity. But neither of us could quite settle into it because the silence between us felt like a question we hadn't answered yet.
What was the question? I think it was: are we okay?
The Silence Audit
I started paying attention to this in other couples after I noticed it in us. The results were illuminating.
My friend Priya and her husband have been together for nine years. I visited them last year and spent an afternoon at their place. At some point we all just stopped talking. Priya was on her laptop. Her husband was reading. I was scrolling through my phone. Nobody said anything for maybe forty minutes. Nobody seemed to notice. Nobody seemed bothered.
I noticed. I noticed because it was so easy. The silence in that room had a quality to it that I can only describe as settled. Like the room itself had exhaled.
I asked Priya about it later. When did that happen, the comfortable silence? She thought about it. "I don't know exactly," she said. "At some point we just stopped needing to fill it."
Compare this to another couple I know, together for five years, who cannot sit in the same room without the television on. Not because they're watching it. Just because the background noise makes the silence feel less pointed. Without it, one of them gets anxious. The quiet feels like something is wrong. The TV is not entertainment. It's a buffer.
They're not in a bad relationship. They just haven't found the silence yet.
What the Silence Actually Means
Comfortable silence is not the absence of connection. It's the presence of enough connection that you don't need to keep proving it.
Early in relationships, conversation is how you establish that you like each other, that you're interested, that being together is better than being apart. You talk because talking is evidence. Every question you ask, every story you share, every laugh you manufacture slightly louder than it needs to be is a small deposit into the account of we are good together.
At some point, if you're lucky, the account gets full enough that you can stop making deposits for a while. You can just sit there. You don't need to prove anything. The silence isn't empty. It's full of everything you've already established.
My husband and I had our first genuinely comfortable silence about two and a half years in. I remember it clearly because I noticed it while it was happening. We were on the couch on a Sunday evening. He was watching something on his tablet with headphones in. I was reading. I had made tea and put Sunfeast Marie Light on the plate between us without asking him if he wanted any because I already knew he would. He took one without looking up. I took one without looking up.
We stayed like that for about an hour.
At some point I thought: oh. So this is what it feels like.
It felt like home.
Why Some Couples Never Get There
Not every couple finds the comfortable silence and I've thought about why.
Some couples never stop performing. They've built a relationship on a certain version of themselves and stepping out of it, even briefly, feels unsafe. The silence would reveal something. They're not sure what. So they keep the noise going.
Some couples have confused activity with intimacy. They're always doing something together, always busy, always on to the next thing, because slowing down might force them to check whether they actually enjoy just being around each other. The busyness is a way of not finding out.
And some couples are just genuinely not compatible in their quiet. One person needs company to be social, the other needs solitude to recharge. This isn't a flaw. It just means the silence will always feel slightly lopsided and they'll need to figure out what that means for them.
But for the couples who do find it, the comfortable silence is one of the better things. It means you've stopped auditioning for each other. It means the relationship has moved past the phase of proving itself and into the phase of just being itself.
The Test, If You Want One
I sometimes think the comfortable silence is a better test of a relationship than the big moments. It's easy to be together when something exciting is happening. Being together when nothing is happening, and finding that completely sufficient, is the real thing.
Can you sit in the same room and read without narrating? Can you have breakfast without a conversation happening? Can you drive somewhere without music or talk radio filling every gap?
If yes, you've probably found something worth keeping.
If not, don't panic. It took us two years and an embarrassing number of unnecessary tea offers. Some things just need time to settle.
The silence, when it comes, is worth the wait.
